Focus Problem: ...Could you stumble upon a bear on a path in the woods?...

js560000

New member
Joined
Feb 25, 2017
Messages
4
This is a problem that was given to my son in school. I am not sure how to help him. I spoke to his teacher. She said that it is extra credit, but she is not going to help.

If you have ever spent any time in a wilderness area, you have likely wondered about the animals there and your safety. Could you stumble upon a bear on a path in the woods? Could you accidentally come between a moose and her calf? What should you do? It's said that you should never run from a bear, for example, but is that always true? What if the bear is far enough away from you that you think you can get away before it catches you? How far away would you need to be in order to be safe?


Obviously, any serious consideration or calculation has to be done well before you actually encounter a wild animal and must face this decision. We know the top speed at which many animals can run, and we know how long they are able to maintain that top speed. This information is shown in the table for a few animals.


Let's assume that the average person can run 10 miles per hour (at least for short distances while being chased). Let's also assume that a person and an animal each achieve top speed immediately. Determine how much of a head start you would need in order to escape from each animal listed in the table if it was chasing you at full speed. From which animal would you need the greatest head start? Consider that each animal can maintain its top speed for only a certain distance. You can use that distance to determine how long the animal can run and, therefore, how much time it has to catch you. How far can you run in that time? When you calculate the head start that you would need, you are determining the minimum safe distance to be away from that animal. This is useful information to know before heading into that animal's natural habitat. Choose one of the animals listed in the table and write an equation to model its distance run vs. time. Write a separate equation to model your distance from the animal vs. time. Graph both of these equations on the same coordinate grid. Explain how the graphs illuminate the situation. What does the slope represent Where do the graphs intersect, and how do you interpret that point? What do they-intercepts represent? Finally, choose another animal that you are interested in and find the minimum safe distance from it. When we're considering running from a wild animal or head*ing into its natural habitat, we have to consider ...

This focus problem can be solved in many different but related ways. You might begin by trying to understand the issues numerically by "running the numbers." At some point, though, you might discover that representing the informa*tion in equations might be more efficient. And, if you're trying to explain what you've discovered about the issues to someone else, a graph might be the most useful way to do it. It's important that you can use multiple representations not only to solve a problem but also to explain your solution to an audience. This is true for the focus problem as well as for many other problems that you'll solve during this cycle. The question "When is it worth it?" will be the focus of the third cycle of the book. Sometimes the focus will be on
determining when it is worth it to use algebraic methods. Other times, the question will relate to particular contexts, such as buying a hybrid vs. gas-powered car or buying an e-reader vs. books. By the end of the cycle, you'll have many tools that you can use to answer this type of question.


You will see periodic sticky notes throughout the cycle to encourage you to keep working on your solution to this prob*lem as you learn new methods to apply.
 

Attachments

  • math table.jpg
    math table.jpg
    56.2 KB · Views: 48
Last edited by a moderator:
This is a problem that was given to my son in school. I am not sure how to help him. I spoke to his teacher. She said that it is extra credit, but she is not going to help.

If you have ever spent any time in a wilderness area, you have likely wondered about the animals there and your safety. Could you stumble upon a bear on a path in the woods? Could you accidentally come between a moose and her calf? What should you do? It's said that you should never run from a bear, for example, but is that always true? What if the bear is far enough away from you that you think you can get away before it catches you? How far away would you need to be in order to be safe?

Obviously, any serious consideration or calculation has to be done well before you actually encounter a wild animal and must face this decision. We know the top speed at which many animals can run, and we know how long they are able to maintain that top speed. This information is shown in the table for a few animals.

Let's assume that the average person can run 10 miles per hour (at least for short distances while being chased). Let's also assume that a person and an animal each achieve top speed immediately. Determine how much of a head start you would need in order to escape from each animal listed in the table if it was chasing you at full speed. From which animal would you need the greatest head start? Consider that each animal can maintain its top speed for only a certain distance. You can use that distance to determine how long the animal can run and, therefore, how much time it has to catch you. How far can you run in that time? When you calculate the head start that you would need, you are determining the minimum safe distance to be away from that animal. This is useful information to know before heading into that animal's natural habitat. Choose one of the animals listed in the table and write an equation to model its distance run vs. time. Write a separate equation to model your distance from the animal vs. time. Graph both of these equations on the same coordinate grid. Explain how the graphs illuminate the situation. What does the slope represent Where do the graphs intersect, and how do you interpret that point? What do they-intercepts represent? Finally, choose another animal that you are interested in and find the minimum safe distance from it. When we're considering running from a wild animal or head*ing into its natural habitat, we have to consider ...

This focus problem can be solved in many different but related ways. You might begin by trying to understand the issues numerically by "running the numbers." At some point, though, you might discover that representing the informa*tion in equations might be more efficient. And, if you're trying to explain what you've discovered about the issues to someone else, a graph might be the most useful way to do it. It's important that you can use multiple representations not only to solve a problem but also to explain your solution to an audience. This is true for the focus problem as well as for many other problems that you'll solve during this cycle. The question "When is it worth it?" will be the focus of the third cycle of the book. Sometimes the focus will be on
determining when it is worth it to use algebraic methods. Other times, the question will relate to particular contexts, such as buying a hybrid vs. gas-powered car or buying an e-reader vs. books. By the end of the cycle, you'll have many tools that you can use to answer this type of question.

You will see periodic sticky notes throughout the cycle to encourage you to keep working on your solution to this prob*lem as you learn new methods to apply.
Please have your son reply with a clear listing of his thoughts and efforts so far, specifying where he is getting stuck.

Thank you! ;)
 
The project has been designed for solving with linear equations (for example, by modeling that all top speeds are attained instantly, for both the human and the animals).

Note that the speeds in the chart are given in miles-per-hour, so all of the distances need to be measured in miles. Three of the distances are given in meters. A first step could be to convert those measurements to miles.

After that, the student needs to be familiar with creating and using linear equations. The student also needs to have learned the relationship between: distance traveled, rate of travel (speed), and elapsed time.

For each situation, I would begin by drawing a diagram, and labeling it with what is already known, using symbols to represent what is not yet known. A diagram can help with creating equations. :cool:
 
The polar bear would run 3 minutes a mile
The black bear would run 2 minutes and 24 seconds
lion would run for 2 minutes
A moose would run 1 minute and 2 seconds
A rhino would run 1 minute and 42 seconds.
 
The polar bear would run 3 minutes a mile
The black bear would run 2 minutes and 24 seconds
lion would run for 2 minutes
A moose would run 1 minute and 2 seconds
A rhino would run 1 minute and 42 seconds.
OK, you are thinking, but maybe not expressing your thought in the clearest way. Consider the polar bear. It is going to stop after 1 mile. Until it stops it will be running at 20 miles an hour. So how long a time will it take for the bear to run that mile? I think you meant to say that the polar bear will run for 3 minutes. That is good thinking. How far can you run (according to the assumptions of the problem) in 3 minutes? So how far away from that polar bear should you be if you do not want to be a bear's lunch?
 
Do you think this is right?
 

Attachments

  • 1.jpg
    1.jpg
    17.9 KB · Views: 38
  • 2.jpg
    2.jpg
    17.5 KB · Views: 43
Hello

The polar bear would run 3 minutes a mile
The black bear would run 2 minutes and 24 seconds
lion would run for 2 minutes
A moose would run 1 minute and 2 seconds
A rhino would run 1 minute and 42 seconds.
How did you get those new numbers? By doing t=D/r ?? I don’t get those minutes. For the black bear I got 0.08 hrs.
 
Top