# Thread: Derivative of 1/cosx^2

1. Originally Posted by Jomo
So we can't calculate sin(cos(x))???
I don't understand your statement (followed by question marks). Do you have a value for x?

2. Originally Posted by Otis
It's not ambiguous, for folks who understand function notation. Is your position that it shouldn't be used because you think a majority of people do not understand function notation?
No, I claim it is not consistent function notation for the exponentiation
of trig functions to begin with.

3. Originally Posted by lookagain
The former is poor form if it is intended to be equivalent for the square of the cosine of x, because it has ambiguous style. It should not be used.

Extra grouping symbols should be used for it instead, such as:

$[cos(x)]^2$
I agree that $\cos(x)^2$ is at least a little ambiguous, and therefore risky to use, especially with inexperienced readers.

In a context where one always uses parentheses around function arguments, it is not ambiguous. So programmers will have no doubt as to what is intended.

But in trig and log problems in textbooks, it is still common to use the old, pre-function notation where $\cos x$ or $\log x$ is acceptable. And in that context, consider a slightly worse case: $\cos(x+1)^2$. Here, the parentheses might be present to mark the argument, $x+1$; or they might be there to distinguish the base of the power, the whole thing being the argument.

In an ideal world, a little thought may make it clear that the parentheses are intended to hold the argument; but expecting everyone to think carefully is "blaming the victim". Consideration for the reader demands that we remove stumbling blocks in case they are not accustomed to seeing things the same way we do. That's how good communication works: the transmitter plans the content to prevent errors on the part of the receiver, rather than putting the entire burden on the receiver.

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•