Interesting little problem?

The Highlander

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2022
Messages
1,229
I thought this might be an interesting exercise for some to practise their algebra...

ab = 100
bc = 200
ca = 300


Find the (exact) value of: a + b + c

I'm not asking for any help or suggestions (I already have two separate procedures to get to the answer) I just thought it would be interesting to see how others approach it.

If you can be bothered to tackle it then please post your solution(s) in full.

NB: The answer should be an exact value, ie: left as a (fully simplified) surd multiple not a decimal approximation.
 
From the third equation [imath]c = \dfrac{300}{a}[/imath]

Plug into the second equation and simplify to get [imath]\dfrac{b}{a}=\dfrac{2}{3}[/imath] so [imath]b=\dfrac{2a}{3}[/imath]

Plug into the first equation and simplify to get [imath]a^2=150[/imath]

Square root and back substitute.
 
I find this approach appealing because it avoids almost all algebra and works directly with the symmetry of the given products.


Given:
[math]ab=100,\quad bc=200,\quad ca=300[/math]
We reconstruct each variable symmetrically:
[math]a = \sqrt{\frac{ab \cdot ac}{bc}}, \quad b = \sqrt{\frac{ab \cdot bc}{ca}}, \quad c = \sqrt{\frac{bc \cdot ca}{ab}}[/math]
Then (up to a global sign),
[math]a = \pm 5\sqrt{6}, \quad b = \pm \frac{10\sqrt{6}}{3}, \quad c = \pm 10\sqrt{6}[/math]
Hence,
[math]a+b+c = \pm \frac{55\sqrt{6}}{3}.[/math]
 
I find this approach appealing because it avoids almost all algebra and works directly with the symmetry of the given products.
Given: \(\displaystyle \quad ab=100,\quad bc=200,\quad ca=300\)
We reconstruct each variable symmetrically:\(\displaystyle \quad a = \sqrt{\frac{ab\cdot ac}{bc}}, \quad b = \sqrt{\frac{ab \cdot bc}{ca}}, \quad c = \sqrt{\frac{bc \cdot ca}{ab}}\)
Then (up to a global sign),\(\displaystyle \quad a = \pm 5\sqrt{6}, \quad b = \pm \frac{10\sqrt{6}}{3}, \quad c = \pm 10\sqrt{6}\)
Hence,\(\displaystyle \; a+b+c = \pm \frac{55\sqrt{6}}{3}.\)
Brilliant! I love it.
Some readers might struggle to see how you get from one line to the next but the efficiency & clarity of your post is stunning!
Bravo! 👏👏👏
 
Top