Integral Applications story problem

medicalphysicsguy

New member
Joined
Jan 23, 2012
Messages
28
Greetings,

This is a story problem in my Swokowski Calculus book. I suspect the answer at the back of the book is wrong because I find it hard to believe the answer doesn't have pi in it. I am self-tutoring so any help is greatly appreciated.

"A log having the shape of a right circular cylinder of radius a is lying on its side. A wedge is removed from the log by making a vertical cut and another cut at the angle of 45 degrees, both cuts intersecting at the center of the log. Find the volume of the wedge."

I get: 1/2*pi*a^3 - a^3 .

Book says: 2/3*a^3.

Is it really possible a wedge cut from a cylinder does not have pi in the answer??

My reasoning is, the x length of the wedge is a due to the 45 degree cut. For a given partition approaching size 0, the volume will be the half-circle representing that slice of the cylinder times dx, minus the square representing that slice of the wedge times dx. Therefore, you integrate from 0 to a the area of the half-circle 1/2*pi*a^2dx minus the area of the square 2axdx.

Can anyone help, thank you.
 
The cross section of the wedge has no circular portion. Does your interpretaton include a circular portion?
 
Picture right triangles going along the length of the wedge with height h and length x.

The wedge is cut with angle θ\displaystyle \theta

Thus, we have tanθ=hx,   h=xtanθ\displaystyle tan\theta = \frac{h}{x}, \;\ h=xtan\theta

The area of each triangle is A(y)=12hx=12x2tanθ\displaystyle A(y)=\frac{1}{2}hx=\frac{1}{2}x^{2}tan\theta

=12(a2y2)tanθ\displaystyle =\frac{1}{2}(a^{2}-y^{2})tan\theta.

because x2=a2y2\displaystyle x^{2}=a^{2}-y^{2}.

V=12tanθaa(a2y2)dy\displaystyle V=\displaystyle \frac{1}{2}tan\theta \int_{-a}^{a}(a^{2}-y^{2})dy

=tanθ0a(a2y2)dy=23a3tanθ\displaystyle =\displaystyle tan\theta \int_{0}^{a}(a^{2}-y^{2})dy=\frac{2}{3}a^{3}tan\theta

Since tan(π4)=1\displaystyle tan(\frac{\pi}{4})=1, we get 23a3\displaystyle \frac{2}{3}a^{3}

No Pi :)
 
Thanks

Many thinks to you both. I found another textbook that uses the exact same method you describe. My reasoning was way off. I don't think my book chapter got me ready for this problem. There was no trig in the chapter, and we really haven't tackled 3-D formally yet, just some tricks for solids that involve rotating a shape around an axis, which I don't think was sufficient for this problem.
 
Top