- Thread starter apple2357
- Start date

- Joined
- Dec 30, 2014

- Messages
- 3,344

What have you tried? Please show us your work. Did you try 1* 1/2* 1/4? How about (1/2)^3... If you want to guess the answer then these are the things you need to try. If this fails then it is time for heavy algebra.I am trying to find an efficient way of solving

cosxcos4xcos8x=1/8, 0 to 2pi, i am thinking about the product of three trig expressions and what must be the case to equal 1/8.

The alternatives feel too heavy algebraically?

Yes, i was trying different possible products! and wondering if there is some kind of symmetry to exploit.What have you tried? Please show us your work. Did you try 1* 1/2* 1/4? How about (1/2)^3... If you want to guess the answer then these are the things you need to try. If this fails then it is time for heavy algebra.

I have tried sketching it for inspiration.

- Joined
- Nov 12, 2017

- Messages
- 3,359

After making some attempts at using various identities to simplify the equation, I put it into Wolfram Alpha to see whether it at least ends up with nice solutions. It turns out that there are a couple solutions that you can find by trial and error, among 16 solutions per cycle, the rest of which are horrendous (involving a 12th degree equation). So I doubt that you will be able to manually find all solutions, though you can find a couple.Yes, i was trying different possible products! and wondering if there is some kind of symmetry to exploit.

I have tried sketching it for inspiration.

Where did the problem come from? Were you given any reason to think it could be solved?

But after musing on it for a while, like you, i haven't made much progress.

I will get back to him in a bit for the 'trick' but wanted to thrash it around on here first!

- Joined
- Dec 30, 2014

- Messages
- 3,344

After learning the trick please report back here!

But after musing on it for a while, like you, i haven't made much progress.

I will get back to him in a bit for the 'trick' but wanted to thrash it around on here first!

- Joined
- Dec 30, 2014

- Messages
- 3,344

Just thinking out loud. How about letting u=4x, 2x=u/2 and 8x = 2u. Will it simplify using the half angle and double angle formulas? I suspect not, since Dr P tried using various identities to simplify the equation with no luck.I am trying to find an efficient way of solving

cosxcos4xcos8x=1/8, 0 to 2pi, i am thinking about the product of three trig expressions and what must be the case to equal 1/8.

The alternatives feel too heavy algebraically?

- Joined
- Nov 12, 2017

- Messages
- 3,359

I can see how that would help (up to a point) for a slightly different equation; but I don't yet see how to use it here.I have been given a hint:

Try multiplying by sinx!

Just to make sure, did you copy the equation correctly? We have it as

cos(x) cos(4x) cos(8x) = 1/8

yes i believe thats correct. I have just asked him to confirm!I can see how that would help (up to a point) for a slightly different equation; but I don't yet see how to use it here.

Just to make sure, did you copy the equation correctly? We have it as

cos(x) cos(4x) cos(8x) = 1/8

- Joined
- Nov 12, 2017

- Messages
- 3,359

- Joined
- Jun 18, 2007

- Messages
- 18,193

Now then follow the hint and show us what do you get.Yes!

My mistake. So sorry!

What a mess up.

The original question is cosx cos2x cos4x = 1/8

- Joined
- Dec 30, 2014

- Messages
- 3,344

You are an amazing mathematician.

I'll second that!You are an amazing mathematician.

so multiply by sinxNow then follow the hint and show us what do you get.

sinx cosx cos2x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

1/2 sin2x cos2x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

(1/2)(1/2)sin4x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

(1/8) sin8x = (1/8) sinx

so sin8x = sinx

i think we can do some general solution stuff from here?

- Joined
- Nov 12, 2017

- Messages
- 3,359

Yes; now we ask ourselves, what is the relationship between two angles that have the same sine? There are two main relationships possible.so multiply by sinx

sinx cosx cos2x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

1/2 sin2x cos2x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

(1/2)(1/2)sin4x cos4x = 1/8 sinx

(1/8) sin8x = (1/8) sinx

so sin8x = sinx

i think we can do some general solution stuff from here?

- Joined
- Dec 30, 2014

- Messages
- 3,344

Why not just check these values in the original equation to see if they work? Can you show us your work that lead to 8x = x+ 360n or 180-x +360nso would this lead to 8x = x+ 360n or 180-x +360n

x = (360/7)n or x = 20 +40n

Is that correct?

- Joined
- Nov 12, 2017

- Messages
- 3,359

These are equivalent to my two sets of solutions (though I used radians, as we normally do in solving trig equations).so would this lead to 8x = x+ 360n or 180-x +360n

x = (360/7)n or x = 20 +40n

Is that correct?

Have you tried graphing and comparing what you see to your solutions?